| Game | Date | Home Team | Away Team | Form | League Position | |||||
| 49 | 20/05/2012 | W | Luton | 1 | York | 2 | ||||
| 48 | 07/05/2012 | D | Mansfield | 0 | York | 0 | ||||
| 47 | 02/05/2012 | D | York | 1 | Mansfield | 1 | ||||
| 46 | 28/04/2012 | W | York | 1 | Forest Green | 0 |  | (H) | 4th |  |
| 45 | 21/04/2012 | W | Braintree Town | 0 | York | 1 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 44 | 17/04/2012 | W | Cambridge Utd | 0 | York | 1 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 43 | 14/04/2012 | D | York | 1 | Newport County | 1 | | (H) | 5th | |
| 42 | 09/04/2012 | W | Alfreton Town | 0 | York | 2 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 41 | 07/04/2012 | L | York | 0 | Fleetwood Town | 1 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 40 | 03/04/2012 | L | Newport County | 2 | York | 1 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 39 | 30/03/2012 | W | Luton | 1 | York | 2 |  | (H) | 4th | |
| 38 | 27/03/2012 | W | Bath | 0 | York | 1 | | (H) | 5th | |
| 37 | 24/03/2012 | L | York | 1 | Southport | 2 | | (H) | 6th | |
| 36 | 13/03/2012 | W | Grimsby | 2 | York | 3 | | (H) | 5th | |
| 35 | 06/03/2012 | D | York | 0 | Tamworth | 0 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 34 | 03/03/2012 | W | York | 2 | Hayes and Yeading | 0 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 33 | 22/02/2012 | L | York | 1 | Gateshead | 2 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 32 | 18/02/2012 | W | York | 2 | Stockport | 1 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 31 | 28/01/2012 | D | Darlington | 2 | York | 2 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 30 | 24/01/2012 | D | Kidderminster | 1 | York | 1 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 29 | 21/01/2012 | W | York | 3 | Ebbsfleet Utd | 2 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 28 | 07/01/2012 | W | Lincoln City | 0 | York | 2 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 27 | 01/01/2012 | D | York | 2 | Mansfield | 2 | | (H) | 5th | |
| 26 | 26/12/2011 | D | Mansfield | 1 | York | 1 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 25 | 19/12/2011 | L | York | 2 | Kidderminster | 3 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 24 | 06/12/2011 | D | Telford Utd | 0 | York | 0 | | (H) | 3rd | |
| 23 | 03/12/2011 | W | York | 7 | Kettering | 0 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 22 | 29/11/2011 | W | York | 2 | Lincoln City | 0 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 21 | 26/11/2011 | D | Forest Green | 1 | York | 1 | | (H) | 5th | |
| 20 | 19/11/2011 | D | Barrow | 0 | York | 0 | | (H) | 5th | |
| 19 | 05/11/2011 | D | York | 0 | Wrexham | 0 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 18 | 22/10/2011 | W | Hayes and Yeading | 2 | York | 4 | | (H) | 3rd | |
| 17 | 18/10/2011 | D | York | 2 | Cambridge Utd | 2 | | (H) | 3rd | |
| 16 | 15/10/2011 | W | York | 2 | Grimsby | 1 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 15 | 11/10/2011 | D | Southport | 1 | York | 1 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 14 | 08/10/2011 | W | York | 6 | Braintree Town | 2 | | (H) | 4th | |
| 13 | 01/10/2011 | W | Stockport | 1 | York | 2 | | (H) | 7th | |
| 12 | 27/09/2011 | L | Gateshead | 3 | York | 2 | | (H) | 8th | |
| 11 | 24/09/2011 | W | York | 3 | Luton | 0 | | (H) | 5th | |
| 10 | 20/09/2011 | D | York | 2 | Darlington | 2 | | (H) | 7th | |
| 9 | 17/09/2011 | W | Wrexham | 0 | York | 3 | | (H) | 8th | |
| 8 | 13/09/2011 | W | York | 1 | Bath | 0 | | (H) | 9th | |
| 7 | 10/09/2011 | L | Tamworth | 2 | York | 1 | | (H) | 14th | |
| 6 | 29/08/2011 | L | York | 0 | Alfreton Town | 1 | | (H) | 6th | |
| 5 | 26/08/2011 | D | Fleetwood Town | 0 | York | 0 | | (H) | 3rd | |
| 4 | 23/08/2011 | W | Kettering | 1 | York | 5 | | (H) | 3rd | |
| 3 | 20/08/2011 | L | York | 0 | Telford Utd | 1 | | (H) | 5th | |
| 2 | 16/08/2011 | W | York | 3 | Barrow | 1 | | (H) | 2nd | |
| 1 | 13/08/2011 | W | Ebbsfleet Utd | 1 | York | 2 | | (H) | 5th | |
